Wagenbach arrives after nine seasons in the New Jersey Titans organization, most recently as the head coach of the Tier I Midget U16 and U18 American teams. The former NJ Rocket was inducted into the New Jersey High School Hall of Fame in 2012 as well as the Christian Brothers Academy Hall of Fame in 2013. Wagenbach ended his playing career at The College of New Jersey, a member of the American Collegiate Hockey Association before entering coaching in 2001.